Tick Tock Goes the Population Bomb

Overpopulation woes include there being too many rich people; it is more than simply a numbers game.

After I sent my US biologist friend Dr James Lazell a recent column on global warming, he also suggested I write about human overpopulation. This seems a thornier issue for conservation than even climate change, as debates can feature religion, racism, eugenics and genocide.

            Yet overpopulation has long been a concern to me, and seems timely in Hong Kong – given arguments raging over mainland tourists dubbed “locusts”, housing threats to country parks, and outrageous plans such building artificial islands for shopping malls, housing and a giant incinerator.

            “Great!!” Lazell replied on learning I would indeed cover overpopulation. “Remember my favorite stat: Americans are 320 million people and consume 40% of all annually available resources. 320 is to 40 as X is to 100…. Fewer than 1 billion people can live on Earth at the American standard of living…. Overpopulation is the Mother of All our Problems; all-out-War will come….”

            Yikes! You might think. That wasn’t the feel-good banter I hope for in a Sunday column.

            Yet Lazell is far from the only person to make doom-laden warnings about humanity’s burgeoning numbers. One of the best known was English clergyman and scholar Thomas Robert Malthus, who in 1798 published An Essay on the Principle of Population, with pronouncements including, “The power of population is so superior to the power of the earth to produce subsistence for man, that premature death must in some shape or other visit the human race.”

            More recently, in 1968, The Population Bomb by Stanford University professor Paul R. Ehrlich and wife Anna warned of massive famines during the 1970s.

            These dire predictions have so far proven wrong, with the human population more than tripling from around a billion in 1798 to over 3.5 billion as The Population Bomb appeared, and more than doubling in the years since, to reach 7 billion and growing today.

            To some people, this shows Malthus and the Erhlichs were just plain wrong. Others – like Lazell – instead believe that in time they will be proven right, and it is only unforeseen events like the industrial revolution and the “green revolution” that helped feed many more people and stave off catastrophe.

            Economist Julian Simon was among the strongest proponents of the idea humanity was nowhere chose to approaching limits. He famously won a wager with Paul Ehrlich that the prices of five metals would fall during ten years from 1980. Yet he would have lost the bet in each decade since, and his astonishingly rosy-tinted view of the future was reflected in an assertion made in 1994, when he wrote that we have, “the technology to feed, clothe and supply energy to an ever-growing population for the next 7 billion years.” This was ridiculed, including by Paul and Anna Ehrlich, who noted that after 6000 years at 1994 growth rates, the mass of the human population would equal the mass of the universe.

            WWF (World Wide Fund for Nature) publishes an annual report about the human footprint on the planet, a measure of how much we are using the Earth’s natural resources.  Last year, the report found that globally, it would take 1.5 Earths to produce all the renewable resources we use. Hong Kong people are living even further beyond Earth’s limits, with 2.6 Earths needed if everyone lived like Hongkongers (surely a substantial underestimate). In tandem with the report, WWF-Hong Kong gave recommendations for how to live more sustainably, such as taking public transport and buying efficient appliances. But one recommendation was notably absent: “Have less children”.

In researching this column, I learned that WWF does not have a policy on population, and wondered if this is because the issue is too controversial. Political leanings and religious beliefs – like the absurd notion we should, “Go forth and multiply” – help dissuade discussions, but even some conservationists recoil at the notion that overpopulation is a problem. British environmental writer George Monbiot wrote an acerbic article with the claim, “Most of those who are obsessed with population growth are post-reproductive wealthy white men,” and instead said the real troubles stem from consumption by rich people like owners of super yachts.

Which surely means that overpopulation woes include there being too many rich people; it is more than simply a numbers game. And as Jared Diamond shows in his book Collapse, human societies were failing from unsustainable growth and unsound policies long before there were super yachts. Angkor Wat and Easter Island are among places where he believes civilisations thrived, then failed through over-straining environments.

In China, Mao Zedong encouraged population growth with a zeal Julian Simon might have applauded, saying, “Every stomach has a pair of hands”. China’s population more than doubled, resulting in severe environmental strains, and by 1979 the post-Mao government introduced the one-child policy. Today, China’s economy is surging yet there are staggering environmental problems, such as filthy waterways and air pollution choking cities.

Here in Hong Kong, we’re all too familiar with air pollution, and there are concerns over water supplies. Original forests are long gone, much as primary forests are dwindling worldwide. The world’s fisheries are depleted, soils are thinning, and greenhouse gas emissions from human activities are transforming climate systems and raising sea levels.

Overpopulation is an issue with no easy solution, though education and access to contraception are important: every sperm is not sacred! It is not something to be downplayed, with the foolish belief that we can always rely on our ingenuity to avoid calamity.

            This latter point was recognised by Norman Borlaug, a pivotal figure in the green revolution. In his 1970 Nobel acceptance speech, he said, “There can be no permanent progress in the battle against hunger until the agencies that fight for increased food production and those that fight for population control unite in a common effort.”

            As yet, there is no such unity. Among indicators of the ballooning importance of overpopulation, the LA Times recently quoted Hans-Joachim Braun, Borlaug’s successor at the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center in Texcoco, Mexico, as saying, “In the next 50 years, we will need to produce as much food as has been consumed over our entire human history.” This comes as global crop yields are reaching a plateau, and amidst concerns over supplies of phosphorus required for fertilisers.

            British wildlife television presenter Sir David Attenborough last year belied his genial disposition by saying, “We are a plague on earth.” Though not warning of war like Lazell, he too had a stark view of the situation: “Either we limit our population growth or the natural world will do it for us.”

Early warnings of climate change
Early warnings of climate change

While climate change resulting from human activities might seem a new-fangled concept, there have been on-point predictions dating back many years.…

Ignoring Science Makes Global Climate Disaster as Inevitable as Titanic Submarine Implosion
Ignoring Science Makes Global Climate Disaster as Inevitable as Titanic Submarine Implosion

Climate change has been prominent in worldwide news this summer (2023), notably as we have just lived through the hottest week…

Have you been bullied into health? Fear, quackery and Covid
Have you been bullied into health? Fear, quackery and Covid

So here we are with our modern-day wonder, the internet – where even with a smartphone, you can search for and…

Never mind the antimask-o-sphere. Science shows face masks help reduce Covid spread
Never mind the antimask-o-sphere. Science shows face masks help reduce Covid spread

Just had one of those silly Twitter “conversations” with someone who had position so fixed, impossible to change with facts. Yeah,…

A Covid scrapbook: snapshots from the crazy pandemic
A Covid scrapbook: snapshots from the crazy pandemic

I’ve read accounts of the Spanish Flu, which was the last major pandemic, mainly in 1918 [so over and done with…

Highly pathogenic bird flu variants mostly evolve in intensive poultry farming
Highly pathogenic bird flu variants mostly evolve in intensive poultry farming

Highly pathogenic bird flu variants evolve from regular, low pathogenic, bird flus, within intensive poultry farming.

Keep Your Underpants Duck Taped and Air Clean as Covid Wild Ride Continues
Keep Your Underpants Duck Taped and Air Clean as Covid Wild Ride Continues

We’ve learned a lot about Covid, even developing vaccines. Yet Covid remains an issue, no matter how much we might wish…

Covid is airborne so ventilation and air filtration are important
Covid is airborne so ventilation and air filtration are important

Since early in the pandemic, I’ve been seeing scientists arguing Covid is airborne, even with hashtag #covidisairborne – including to counter…

Long Covid – info and links indicating major impact
Long Covid – info and links indicating major impact

Evidence is snowballing that Long Covid is also a serious issue, even affecting people in whom the disease initially appeared mild.

Perhaps Covid arose through lab leak of tweaked bat Coronavirus
Perhaps Covid arose through lab leak of tweaked bat Coronavirus

Maybe humans tweaked bat coronaviruses in gain of function experiments, inadvertently creating Covid thro lab leak.

The Covid Conundrum: Endless Lockdowns, Let It Rip … or What?
The Covid Conundrum: Endless Lockdowns, Let It Rip … or What?

Covid is airborne, which means that much as unprotected sex is a risk for HIV, unprotected breathing might result in Covid.

Science shows Covid including Omicron is Really Not the Flu
Science shows Covid including Omicron is Really Not the Flu

Some of the science showing Covid including Omicron is a huge issue; and one that looks set to be with us…

“Alarmist” Covid predictions outperform Covid deniers’ soothsaying
“Alarmist” Covid predictions outperform Covid deniers’ soothsaying

The disinfo downplaying Covid is often from rightwing, mainly money-minded folks who perhaps don’t care too much about actual people.

Covid virulence, vaccines and variants  
Covid virulence, vaccines and variants  

Science can provide some insights into what may happen with Covid, along with ways to limit its impacts.

dummy-img
We’re in the Covid Era for the Long Haul

We’re in this for the long haul, with the virus like a relentless, invisible foe, ready to exploit errors, slip through…

My Strange n Surprising Summer Staycation with Cellulitis
My Strange n Surprising Summer Staycation with Cellulitis

rom quick pricking by unseen marine creature, to intense fever, and hospital stay for an infection deep within the skin.

dummy-img
Covid virulence, vaccines and variants

[Written for South China Morning Post on 6 January 2021] In January last year, as reports were emerging of the new…

dummy-img
The Viral Time Bomb – Pandemic of Our Time

Guan Yi, director of the State Key Laboratory of Emerging Infectious Diseases at Hong Kong University, has extensive experience of viruses;…

From China With Fear: the Wuhan Coronavirus Won’t Kill Us All
From China With Fear: the Wuhan Coronavirus Won’t Kill Us All

As news of Wuhan coronavirus emerges, evolutionary biology suggests potential for a pandemic, not killing high percentage of people.

Fightback Needed as Science and Life Support System Under Attack
Fightback Needed as Science and Life Support System Under Attack

Environmentalism is under assault; yet this planet is the only home we have; providing our food, air, water… It’s our life…

Secret World of Hong Kong Water Supply
Secret World of Hong Kong Water Supply

Hong Kong’s water supply system has been vital to its development as a “world city”.

Hong Kong Belching Buffaloes n Bubbling Paddies and the Mystery Methane Rise
Hong Kong Belching Buffaloes n Bubbling Paddies and the Mystery Methane Rise

Prof Euan Nisbet leads a science team to Hong Kong in quest to help find why levels of potent greenhouse gas…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *